Results: 'Amateur Hour'

scouthoward profile photo
scouthoward

05/25/2026

60

5

1031

Politics
Republican Sen. Thom Tillis has gone scorched earth on “impulsive” Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth over his decision to downgrade the Army’s top command overseeing Europe and Africa. As a result of the downgrade, the Pentagon is replacing four-star Gen. Christopher Donahue with a three-star general or lieutenant general. "GOP senator exposes Pentagon Pete’s 'amateur hour' scheme" by Wiktoria Gucia, The Daily Beast, is the source for this survey.
1.
1.
The North Carolina senator condemned the move as a "careless decision" and called out Hegseth and his "political henchmen" for what he said was an effort to push out some of the military's top officers, calling it "amateur hour at best and deadly at worst." "Hegseth would do well to surround himself with more patriots like General Donahue and to get his henchmen, who are not qualified to carry Donahue's bag, out of the Pentagon," Tillis added. The reported move follows Hegseth's announcement earlier this month that the United States would withdraw 5,000 troops from military posts in Germany. Do you agree with Senator Tillis?
Yes
32%
334 votes
No
14%
141 votes
Undecided
14%
147 votes
Not Applicable
40%
409 votes
2.
2.
The withdrawal from Germany also caused concern among Republican lawmakers, who said they were "very concerned" by the decision, particularly that it was "sending the wrong signal to Vladimir Putin." Tillis, who is not seeking re-election and has vowed to use the remaining days to speak without filter, wrote Saturday that Hegseth "continues to surprise and disrespect our greatest allies and some of our best military professionals." He described his decision-making as "impulsive" and "not grounded in reality or good judgment." Do you think that Defense Secretary Hegseth is qualified for his position?
Yes
13%
129 votes
No
38%
391 votes
Undecided
13%
132 votes
Not Applicable
37%
379 votes
3.
3.
"He is taking another step down a dangerous path," the senator warned. Jim Townsend, a former deputy assistant secretary of defense for Europe and NATO policy, asserted that downgrading General (4 stars) Donahue to the rank of lieutenant general (3 stars) would be a move "against the grain" for allies who see Russia as a threat. "Keep your word, Mr. Secretary: choose meritocracy over your mediocre yes-men," Tillis said. Is it time for President Trump to fire Defense Secretary Hegseth for incompetence and failure to safeguard the nation in a professional manner?
Yes
35%
362 votes
No
11%
118 votes
Undecided
14%
140 votes
Not Applicable
40%
411 votes
4.
4.
President Trump, who is known for his on-and-off relationship with Russia's President Vladimir Putin, previously responded to Tillis' criticism by incorrectly claiming that he is "no longer a senator." The Pentagon did not respond to an email seeking comment. Do you think that President Trump places loyalty to himself above the safety of the nation when he allows this type of behavior from Secretary Hegseth?
Yes
41%
422 votes
No
13%
135 votes
Undecided
10%
98 votes
Not Applicable
36%
376 votes

Comments