Results: Movies better than the books they are based on

Hulagirl56 profile photo
Hulagirl56

08/20/2022

29

2287

Movies
Movie adaptations of books often get a bad rap. And often, it's deserved, but sometimes the movie is better.
Survey Image
1.
1.
Mario Puzo's 1969 novel, The Godfather, is wonderful. It's just that Francis Ford Coppola's 1972 film adaptation is a masterpiece. My own personal sentiment. Have you read The Godfather?
Mario Puzo's 1969 novel, The Godfather, is wonderful. It's just that Francis Ford Coppola's 1972 film adaptation is a masterpiece. My own personal sentiment. Have you read The Godfather?
Yes
20%
444 votes
No
80%
1756 votes
2.
2.
Written in 1986 by Winston Groom, Forrest Gump the novel is almost unidentifiable as the basis for the hit 1994 movie. Aside from the title character's name, the film is a totally different entity. In the book, Forrest grows up healthy and becomes an astronaut who befriends an ape named Sue in space. Have you ever read the book Forrest Gump?
Written in 1986 by Winston Groom, Forrest Gump the novel is almost unidentifiable as the basis for the hit 1994 movie. Aside from the title character's name, the film is a totally different entity. In the book, Forrest grows up healthy and becomes an astronaut who befriends an ape named Sue in space. Have you ever read the book Forrest Gump?
Yes
11%
235 votes
No
89%
1965 votes
3.
3.
Peter Benchley's novel Jaws was a commercial success. However, many critics didn't like the sub-plots, and found the characters unlikeable. For the film, Steven Spielberg asked his screenwriters to make the characters more likeable, and cut the book's subplots. The result made Spielberg a household name, and produced a summer blockbuster like the world had never seen back in 1975. Did you ever read Jaws?
Peter Benchley's novel Jaws was a commercial success. However, many critics didn't like the sub-plots, and found the characters unlikeable. For the film, Steven Spielberg asked his screenwriters to make the characters more likeable, and cut the book's subplots. The result made Spielberg a household name, and produced a summer blockbuster like the world had never seen back in 1975. Did you ever read Jaws?
Yes
19%
409 votes
No
81%
1791 votes
4.
4.
Chuck Palahniuk's Fight Club is a satirical novel about a man struggling to make sense of life in the modern world. You can tell that he really poured all of his pent-up frustration at the publishing industry, consumerism, and contemporary America right into it. Yet, there just is no comparison to the film, which remains a modern favorite for "movie nerds". Brad Pitt and Edward Norton are a dynamic, entertaining duo. The frenetic, anxious energy of the book is captured so perfectly by David Fincher's masterful directing. Have you ever seen Fight Club?
Chuck Palahniuk's Fight Club is a satirical novel about a man struggling to make sense of life in the modern world. You can tell that he really poured all of his pent-up frustration at the publishing industry, consumerism, and contemporary America right into it. Yet, there just is no comparison to the film, which remains a modern favorite for
Yes
24%
528 votes
No
76%
1672 votes
5.
5.
Michael Crichton's book, Jurassic Park, is a fantastic thriller. Of course, when you get Steven Spielberg involved in an already awesome project about freaking dinosaurs in the modern age, things quickly go from really good to great. The book is exciting and well-paced, but the blockbuster is what I immediately think of when I hear the term "movie magic." While the film is quite tame in comparison to the book (likely toned down to achieve a PG-13 rating), Spielberg and his team really brought the prehistoric creatures to life in the most mesmerizing way. Have you ever read the book Jurassic Park?
Michael Crichton's book, Jurassic Park, is a fantastic thriller. Of course, when you get Steven Spielberg involved in an already awesome project about freaking dinosaurs in the modern age, things quickly go from really good to great. The book is exciting and well-paced, but the blockbuster is what I immediately think of when I hear the term
Yes
14%
316 votes
No
86%
1884 votes

Comments