Rewards
Walmart logo
Amazon logo
PayPal logo
Amazon gift card
Take surveys and collect rewards from the industry-leading e-commerce website, Amazon.com, Via "amazon gift cards". The more you take or create survey, larger the amazon gift card you earn.

Results: Indian couple sue only son for not giving them grandchildren

Published on 05/18/2022
By: Tellwut
2916
Parenting
A couple in India are suing their son and daughter-in-law -- for not giving them grandchildren after six years of marriage. Sadhana and Sanjeev Prasad, who live in Haridwar, a city in northern Uttarakhand state, filed a petition this month seeking 50 million Indian rupees (about $643,000) in damages from their son, 35, and his wife, 31.- CNN
1.
1.
Though this kind of lawsuit is rare, the topic of familial obligation has long been controversial in India, where carrying on the family line and caring for elderly parents and in-laws is often seen as a filial duty. In your opinion, is caring for your parents a filial duty (duty of a child to its parents)?
Yes
34%
996 votes
No
39%
1126 votes
Undecided
27%
778 votes
2.
2.
It's also sometimes a legal duty in India: parents can claim a monthly allowance from their adult children under a federal law that seeks to protect parents and senior citizens who may not be able to take care of themselves. Do you think US and Canada should have laws like this?
Yes
15%
436 votes
No
57%
1665 votes
Undecided
28%
799 votes
3.
3.
The couple's legal representative, Arvind Srivastava, said that as the couple ages, "there is no-one to take care of them," and that "all parents wish to be grandparents one day." If you are a parent, or planning to be, do you wish to be a grandparent? If you already are one, did you wish before you were one that you would have grandkids?
Yes
35%
1022 votes
No
18%
515 votes
Undecided
14%
406 votes
Not Applicable
33%
957 votes
4.
4.
In the petition, viewed by CNN, the couple claim they spent about 20 million Indian rupees (about $257,000) raising their son, who is an only child. "They raised him, educated him, made him capable, made him a pilot -- which was expensive," said Srivastava. Do you think children should be responsible for their parents in any of these ways when they become adults?
Take care of them financially
21%
607 votes
Take care of them physically
43%
1257 votes
Pay them back financially for everything they did to raise the child
7%
209 votes
Other (please specify)
7%
205 votes
Not Applicable
40%
1165 votes
COMMENTS