Results for - Science at its best!?

1,691 voters participated in this survey
Have you ever been to the American Museum of Natural History in New York?

1. Have you ever been to the American Museum of Natural History in New York?

Yes
16%
268 votes
No
77%
1,308 votes
Not Applicable
7%
115 votes
Have you ever heard of a Guadalcanal moustached kingfisher?

2. Have you ever heard of a Guadalcanal moustached kingfisher?

Yes
9%
144 votes
No
76%
1,288 votes
Undecided
5%
83 votes
Not Applicable
10%
176 votes

3. Chris Filardi, director of the Pacific Programs at the museum, had been searching for the orange, white, and brilliant-blue bird for more than 20 years. After days of tracking, while on a field study in the high forests of Guadalcanal in the Solomon Islands, he and his colleagues captured a male moustached kingfisher in a mist net. Then the team killed it. They decided to euthanize the bird so it could be studied as a "scientific specimen." Does this surprise you?

Yes
35%
584 votes
No
36%
605 votes
Undecided
11%
189 votes
Not Applicable
19%
313 votes

4. Ornithology records only indicate that the bird is "rare," with anywhere between 250 and 1,000 surviving in the wild. Landowners on the island told the research team the bird was common and a source of food to some. At the density levels the team observed, and with 15 percent of the island containing suitable habitat, Filardi estimates the moustached kingfisher population at around 4,000 and not in imminent danger of extinction. Do you question his estimation of population?

Yes
28%
472 votes
No
19%
321 votes
Undecided
31%
528 votes
Not Applicable
22%
370 votes

5. Since the birds are isolated to Guadalcanal, they face many of the same challenges of other "single-island endemic" animals, such as invasive species, habitat degradation from logging and mining, and shifting temperatures to climate change. According to the researchers, with the collected sample, they have a more comprehensive set of molecular, morphological, and toxicological data that can't be garnered from blood samples, individual feathers, or photographs. "The specters of extinction for island birds loom in today's world," Filardi wrote. "The collection of a single moustached kingfisher is not among them. And, beyond advancing science, I believe this act will positively impact the kingfisher's world." Do you agree with his statement?

Yes
13%
221 votes
No
21%
352 votes
Undecided
43%
720 votes
Not Applicable
24%
398 votes
11/06/2015 Living 1691 18 By: sarahzahm

Comments

Load more comments...
Loading...
sarahzahm profile photo
By: sarahzahm