Results for - When rebelling meant sneaking a Christmas tree into the White House

1,819 voters participated in this survey
(Source: Cara Giaimo, Rituals Week) President Roosevelt thought trees should stay outdoors - so in 1902, his 8-year-old son Archie took matters into his own hands. Starting at the turn of the century, Christmas trees faced an environmentally-minded backlash. In an editorial, the Minneapolis Times warned that the annual harvest

1. (Source: Cara Giaimo, Rituals Week) President Roosevelt thought trees should stay outdoors - so in 1902, his 8-year-old son Archie took matters into his own hands. Starting at the turn of the century, Christmas trees faced an environmentally-minded backlash. In an editorial, the Minneapolis Times warned that the annual harvest "threatens to strip our forests;" soon after, the Hartford Courant bemoaned what they called "an altogether endless sacrifice… just to meet the calls of an absurd fad." Did you know that in 1902 there were already a lot of people and institutions trying to protect the environment?

Yes
23%
413 votes
No
77%
1,387 votes
The Roosevelts didn't use to have a Christmas tree. Edith Roosevelt probably had enough to deal with: they had 6 rambunctious kids and a growing menagerie of animals. Having so many kids and pets, would you have considered having a Christmas tree anyway?

2. The Roosevelts didn't use to have a Christmas tree. Edith Roosevelt probably had enough to deal with: they had 6 rambunctious kids and a growing menagerie of animals. Having so many kids and pets, would you have considered having a Christmas tree anyway?

Yes
46%
835 votes
No
15%
272 votes
Undecided
20%
364 votes
Not Applicable
18%
329 votes
Archie's plant exploits eventually took on a life of their own. At least one writer has credited Archie as the first person to bring a Christmas tree into the White House. That honor, though disputed, probably belongs to Franklin Pierce. When you were a kid, were you allowed to have a Christmas tree at home?

3. Archie's plant exploits eventually took on a life of their own. At least one writer has credited Archie as the first person to bring a Christmas tree into the White House. That honor, though disputed, probably belongs to Franklin Pierce. When you were a kid, were you allowed to have a Christmas tree at home?

Yes
75%
1,345 votes
No
25%
455 votes
In 1902 Archie had a little Christmas tree of his own which he had rigged up with the help of one of the carpenters in a big closet. A steward had smuggled a two-foot-tall fir top into the White House at the request of Archie, who had hidden it in one of the many unused clothes closets and slowly trussed it up. The eight-year-old then gathered everyone around for the big reveal. All the family was there, but none appeared as astonished as Mr. Roosevelt himself at the sight of this diminutive Christmas tree. There was a present for each family member, including Jack the dog, Tom Quartz the kitten, and Algonquin the pony. Would you consider Archie to be a rebel if this story could take place in 2016 instead of 1902?

4. In 1902 Archie had a little Christmas tree of his own which he had rigged up with the help of one of the carpenters in a big closet. A steward had smuggled a two-foot-tall fir top into the White House at the request of Archie, who had hidden it in one of the many unused clothes closets and slowly trussed it up. The eight-year-old then gathered everyone around for the big reveal. All the family was there, but none appeared as astonished as Mr. Roosevelt himself at the sight of this diminutive Christmas tree. There was a present for each family member, including Jack the dog, Tom Quartz the kitten, and Algonquin the pony. Would you consider Archie to be a rebel if this story could take place in 2016 instead of 1902?

Yes
28%
509 votes
No
36%
642 votes
Undecided
36%
649 votes
12/23/2016 Seasons 1819 18 By: LBP
LBP profile photo
By: LBP
view all surveys

Comments